Within Witness Images
Why Some UFOs Look Like Cigars
Cigar-shaped UFO reports show how witnesses borrow plain comparison words from older airship lore and newer rocket imagery.
On this page
- Airships, rockets, and elongated craft
- How witnesses use practical comparison words
- Why cylinders sit between old and modern UFO lore
Page outline Jump by section
Introduction
Not every classic UFO is described as a flying saucer. Throughout the history of UFO reports, witnesses have repeatedly described long, cylindrical, or “cigar-shaped” objects. What makes these reports especially interesting is that they sit between two different technological imaginations. In the late nineteenth century, people often compared mysterious aerial objects to airships or dirigibles. After the Second World War, witnesses increasingly reached for the language of rockets, missiles, and space travel. The cigar-shaped UFO became a bridge between those worlds: long enough to resemble an airship, streamlined enough to resemble a rocket, and vague enough to absorb changing ideas about advanced technology. This makes cigar UFOs a useful example of how science-fiction imagery and real-world technological expectations can shape witness testimony. [uapwatchers.com]uapwatchers.comthe great mystery airship wave of 1896 97 americas first ufo flapThe Great Mystery Airship Wave of 1896-97: America’s First UFO Flap – UFO – UAP Sightings – UAP Watchers ForumApril 23, 2025…
Airships, rockets, and elongated craft
The elongated UFO template appeared before the modern flying-saucer era. During the American “mystery airship” wave of 1896–1897, witnesses commonly reported large cigar-shaped craft equipped with lights, propellers, and apparent steering mechanisms. Reports often described deliberate movement, hovering, and controlled navigation rather than random atmospheric phenomena. Importantly, observers usually interpreted these objects through the most advanced aviation concepts available to them: experimental airships that had not yet become commonplace. [uapwatchers.com]uapwatchers.comthe great mystery airship wave of 1896 97 americas first ufo flapThe Great Mystery Airship Wave of 1896-97: America’s First UFO Flap – UFO – UAP Sightings – UAP Watchers ForumApril 23, 2025…
Contemporary newspaper descriptions from the period reveal how strongly these reports reflected the technological imagination of the day. Witnesses compared the objects to cartridges, boats, dirigibles, and mechanically powered flying machines. Reports frequently mentioned propellers, side lights, and elongated hulls rather than disc-shaped craft. [San Francisco Story]sanfranciscostory.com1896 ufoSan Francisco Story1896 UFONovember 22, 2023…
After the Second World War, the dominant comparison changed. The development of the German V-2 rocket, the beginning of the missile age, and public fascination with spaceflight gave witnesses a new vocabulary. Reports of “ghost rockets” over Scandinavia in 1946 illustrate this transition. Observers increasingly described mysterious aerial objects as rocket-like cylinders rather than flying ships. The basic elongated shape remained, but its cultural meaning shifted from airship technology to rocketry and space travel. [Reddit]reddit.com1946 Cigar Shaped UFOs!July 28, 2023…
This transition mirrors a broader pattern in UFO history. Witnesses rarely describe unknown objects in entirely novel terms. Instead, they compare them with the most advanced or exciting technologies already present in public imagination.
How witnesses use practical comparison words
When people encounter something ambiguous in the sky, they generally do not produce technical descriptions. They rely on practical comparison words that communicate shape quickly.
For elongated UFO reports, recurring comparison terms include:
- Cigar – emphasising length and cylindrical form.
- Airship – suggesting controlled flight and a visible structure.
- Rocket – implying speed, propulsion, and advanced technology.
- Torpedo – highlighting streamlined shape and apparent power.
- Cylinder – a more neutral geometric description.
These labels often tell historians more about the witness’s cultural reference points than about the object’s actual identity. A person in 1896 was unlikely to describe an unknown object as a spacecraft because spacecraft did not yet exist in public experience. A witness in 1955, surrounded by magazine illustrations of rockets and interplanetary travel, had very different descriptive tools available.
The shape itself also encourages flexible interpretation. A distant lighted object with little visible detail can easily appear elongated depending on viewing angle, atmospheric conditions, or motion. Once a witness settles on a comparison such as “cigar” or “rocket”, later retellings may become more elaborate and more technologically specific. This process helps explain why similar-looking reports can acquire very different narratives across different eras. [The National Archives]nationalarchives.gov.ukThe National Archives UFO reportsThe National ArchivesUFO reports - The National Archives…
Why cylinders sit between old and modern UFO lore
The cigar-shaped UFO occupies a distinctive place in UFO folklore because it comfortably accommodates both older and newer technological dreams.
In nineteenth-century airship stories, elongated craft often appeared as human inventions that were merely ahead of their time. Some reports even featured conversations with supposedly human inventors or crews operating secret machines. The mystery centred on hidden technology rather than extraterrestrial visitors. [uapwatchers.com]uapwatchers.comthe great mystery airship wave of 1896 97 americas first ufo flapThe Great Mystery Airship Wave of 1896-97: America’s First UFO Flap – UFO – UAP Sightings – UAP Watchers ForumApril 23, 2025…
As science fiction matured during the twentieth century, the same elongated form became compatible with interplanetary travel. Long cylindrical craft looked plausible as space vehicles in magazine illustrations, pulp-fiction covers, and early cinematic depictions of spaceflight. A witness no longer needed to imagine a secret inventor; the object could be interpreted as a spacecraft from another world.
This flexibility gave the cigar shape unusual staying power. Unlike the saucer, which became strongly associated with a specific post-1947 UFO image, the cylinder could adapt to changing technological expectations. It could be an advanced dirigible, a missile, a mothership, a futuristic transport, or an alien spacecraft depending on the period and the cultural setting.
Some later UFO traditions even assigned special significance to large cigar-shaped objects as “carrier” craft or “mother ships”. Whether or not such claims were credible, they demonstrate how an originally simple geometric description accumulated layers of science-fiction meaning over time.
A revealing example of cultural continuity
One reason cigar-shaped UFO reports are historically valuable is that they reveal continuity across very different eras of UFO belief. The same basic visual form appears in the airship wave of the 1890s, the rocket-focused atmosphere of the 1940s, and later science-fiction-influenced UFO narratives.
The underlying pattern is not necessarily that witnesses are observing the same phenomenon. Rather, it shows how people repeatedly interpret unusual sights through available technological metaphors. In one generation the metaphor is the airship. In another it is the rocket. The elongated UFO survives because it fits both.
For researchers interested in the relationship between UFOs and science fiction, cigar-shaped sightings provide a particularly clear case study. They demonstrate that witness descriptions are not created in a cultural vacuum. Even when observers are sincere, the language they use often reflects the boundary between existing technology and imagined future technology. The cigar UFO occupies that boundary almost perfectly, positioned between the age of dirigibles and the age of spaceflight.
Amazon book picks
Further Reading
Books and field guides related to Why Some UFOs Look Like Cigars. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.
The UFO Experience
Provides frameworks for analyzing recurring UFO shapes and witness reports.
The Seven Sins of Memory
Explains reconstructive memory, distortion, misattribution, and suggestion—core themes in UFO memory-retelling discussions.
Eyewitness Testimony
Directly addresses eyewitness memory, suggestion, questioning effects, and the reliability of recollected events.
The Demon-haunted World
Explains perception, evidence, belief, and how people interpret ambiguous experiences.
eBay marketplace picks
Marketplace Samples
Example marketplace items related to this page. Use the search link to explore similar finds on eBay.
Endnotes
-
Source: uapwatchers.com
Title: the great mystery airship wave of 1896 97 americas first ufo flap
Link: https://uapwatchers.com/community/ufo-uap-sightings/the-great-mystery-airship-wave-of-1896-97-americas-first-ufo-flap/Source snippet
The Great Mystery Airship Wave of 1896-97: America’s First UFO Flap – UFO – UAP Sightings – UAP Watchers ForumApril 23, 2025...
Published: April 23, 2025
-
Source: reddit.com
Link: https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/15bpoyzSource snippet
1946 Cigar Shaped UFOs!July 28, 2023...
Published: July 28, 2023
-
Source: weeklyuniverse.com
Link: https://www.weeklyuniverse.com/2004/airships.htmSource snippet
The UFO Airships of 1896-1897...
-
Source: sanfranciscostory.com
Title: 1896 ufo
Link: https://www.sanfranciscostory.com/1896-ufo/Source snippet
San Francisco Story1896 UFONovember 22, 2023...
Published: November 22, 2023
-
Source: nationalarchives.gov.uk
Title: The National Archives UFO reports
Link: https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/explore-the-collection/explore-by-time-period/postwar/ufo-reports/Source snippet
The National ArchivesUFO reports - The National Archives...
Additional References
-
Source: ufodatalive.com
Link: https://www.ufodatalive.com/Source snippet
Data Live | U.S. UFO Sightings Database, UAP Tracker & Disclosure Timeline...
-
Source: youtube.com
Title: The Most Bizarre UFO Sightings That Even NASA Can’t Explain
Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNQf3h74IbISource snippet
I Saw a Cigar Shaped Object in the Sky, What Was it? | This Morning...
-
Source: youtube.com
Title: The Ghost Rockets, the Scandinavian UFO ghost rockets!!!
Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Ao7rbTGJzsSource snippet
The Most Bizarre UFO Sightings That Even NASA Can't Explain...
-
Source: youtube.com
Title: [PROJECT BLUE BOOK]({{ ‘blue-book/’ | relative_url }}) | “Operation Paperclips” Sneak Peek
Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RbE3arOv3n8Source snippet
The Ghost Rockets, the Scandinavian UFO ghost rockets...
-
Source: youtube.com
Title: I Saw a Cigar Shaped Object in the Sky, What Was it? | This Morning
Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RKqlNK_IG1w
Topic Tree